You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
So I've been trying to reconstruct some tomo data that has negative values and while I get a pretty nice results with fbp, when I try to run either the ADMM or the PDHG algorithms with the same data, I get only positive results (the exact values vary but mainly increase with the number of iterations) that look somewhat like unfiltered backprojection, even with a very small regularization parameter (1e-50):
FBP reconstruction on the left and ADMM reconstruction on the right (PDHG gives a very similar result to ADMM)
I can restrict the reconstruction space a bit to get rid of the dark corners and get a slightly better contrast but it does not significantly improve the results. I followed the pdhg and admm example codes pretty closely, and tried also to replace the f functional by a [-1,1] box constraint but that seemingly made no difference.
# Stacking of the two operators
L = odl.BroadcastOperator(ray_trafo, grad)
# Data matching and regularization functionals
data_fit = odl.solvers.L2NormSquared(ray_trafo.range).translated(data)
reg_func = 1e-50 * odl.solvers.L2Norm(grad.range)
g = odl.solvers.SeparableSum(data_fit, reg_func)
# We don't use the f functional, setting it to zero
f = odl.solvers.IndicatorBox(L.domain, lower = -1, upper = 1)#odl.solvers.ZeroFunctional(L.domain)
I tried to investigate the proximal operators and the admm/pdhg code but haven't yet found the answer. Is there something I am missing?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
So I've been trying to reconstruct some tomo data that has negative values and while I get a pretty nice results with fbp, when I try to run either the ADMM or the PDHG algorithms with the same data, I get only positive results (the exact values vary but mainly increase with the number of iterations) that look somewhat like unfiltered backprojection, even with a very small regularization parameter (1e-50):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f6704/f6704d744cdd5f41f2dd6f4ec02d26b4e6cc30f6" alt="image"
FBP reconstruction on the left and ADMM reconstruction on the right (PDHG gives a very similar result to ADMM)
I can restrict the reconstruction space a bit to get rid of the dark corners and get a slightly better contrast but it does not significantly improve the results. I followed the pdhg and admm example codes pretty closely, and tried also to replace the f functional by a [-1,1] box constraint but that seemingly made no difference.
I tried to investigate the proximal operators and the admm/pdhg code but haven't yet found the answer. Is there something I am missing?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: